My Top Baby Formula Pick for 2026
US and European formulas, compared side by side
Want the TLDR? I’ve formula-fed two babies from day one, compared 8 different formulas (three American, five European) along the way, and this was my top pick (read on for my entire evaluation and testing process)
HiPP Dutch Stage 1 Combiotik
Check Availability
Right now the US shop I order from runs a buy 3, get 4 starter pack with free shipping, and a Right Formula Guarantee if it turns out not to suit your baby.
What I liked
- Complete organic formula that’s close to breastmilk
- No corn syrup solids, starch, maltodextrin or gluten
- Prebiotic (GOS from lactose)
- Probiotic, specifically lactobacillus fermentum, a strain of beneficial bacteria found in breast milk
- Lactic cultures like those in breast milk
- Includes DHA and ARA
- EU organic certified, skim-milk based, no palm oil
- My spit-up-prone second baby settled on it within a couple of weeks
What could be better
- You won’t find it in a US store, so you order ahead (2–5 business days from a US warehouse)
- The scoop chart is in grams and millilitres, so read it once carefully
My Top Baby Formulas
Eight formulas, ranked after feeding them to my own baby
Meet my little ones
My youngest, the one this whole search was for, guarding the can that finally stuck around :)
My research outcome
I’m a mom of two – a three-year-old and a ten-month-old – and I’ve exclusively formula fed both of my babies, so I’ve spent a lot of late nights reading the back of formula tins. We live in Idaho, where the choice on the shelf is Similac, Enfamil and a couple of organic store brands, and for a long time that was all I knew.
With my first I used Kendamil, and it was fine. With my younger baby we started having issues with spit-up, and he never seemed to stay full. I cycled through a couple of the store options before I heard about HiPP from my massage therapist, who had recommended it to other parents she worked with, and decided to give it a try. We’ve been on it for five months now, and since switching I’ve become pretty particular about the practical details of formula – from getting the bottle ratios right to checking ingredients and making sure I’m ordering enough for the month.
This in-depth, parent-friendly guide will help you find the best formula for your family. You will learn about my experience, what to watch out for when buying European formula in the US, and where you can reliably get the one I chose. I also created a comparison chart that summarizes all of my research. I update this post monthly to ensure that all of the information below is recent and accurate!
Evening bottle, with the ratio chart taped inside the cupboard door.
Someone approves of the latest delivery :)
Why you need to make sure the formula is right for your baby
Finding a formula that suited my baby mattered to me for a few reasons:
1. Every feed is a chance for things to go sideways - With the formulas we tried first, my baby was spitting up after most bottles and acting hungry again an hour later. Nobody in the house slept well, and I was second-guessing everything. Once we found a formula that agreed with him, the evenings calmed down for us. I can’t promise the same for your baby, but I can tell you what to look for.
2. “Organic” and “gentle” on a US label don’t tell you what’s in the tin - A lot of the US formulas marketed for sensitive tummies are built on corn syrup solids or corn maltodextrin instead of lactose. European organic rules are stricter about what goes in, and the ingredient lists are shorter. Check out the Kendamil, HiPP, Holle and Lebenswert ingredient lists – you’ll never find things like corn syrup solids in them.
3. Buying European formula means buying it from someone reliable - These formulas aren’t sold in US stores, so you order online. There are grey-market resellers with old stock and no English instructions. I only order from an established US distributor that ships from a US warehouse, keeps the stock fresh, and will actually answer the phone if a shipment goes missing.
Factors that matter for a baby formula
Since my baby would be living on this stuff for the best part of a year, I was pretty picky about the formula I chose! As a starting point, these were the factors I considered when comparing formulas:
Milk base - I wanted lactose as the carbohydrate, like breast milk, not corn syrup solids, glucose syrup or maltodextrin. This single ingredient line split the eight formulas into two groups straight away.
Organic certification - EU organic (and Demeter for Holle) covers how the cows are raised and fed, not just a handful of ingredients. The US organic formulas I tried still had the corn-based sugars.
Prebiotics and probiotics - Breast milk contains both. Very few formulas contain both. This ended up being the deciding factor for my winner.
DHA and ARA - All EU infant formulas are now required to include DHA. In the US it’s optional, so it’s worth checking the label.
What’s left out - No palm oil, no soy, no added sugar, no gluten, no starch. Shorter list, happier me.
How my baby actually did - Spit-up, gas, how long he stayed full, and how our evenings went. This is just my baby and my notes, not a clinical trial, but it’s what I cared about most.
Cost - Formula adds up fast. Feeding two babies on formula from day one teaches you to look at the price per can, how far a can goes, and whether there’s a subscription or a multi-can deal.
Mixing and ratios - Does it foam or clump, is the scoop-to-water chart printed clearly, and is the scoop a sensible size? I’m particular about ratios (there’s a chart taped inside my cupboard door), and some tins make it harder than it needs to be.
Where you can reliably buy it - Fresh stock, climate-controlled shipping, a US warehouse, and a real customer service team. For imported formula this matters as much as the ingredients.
The formulas I compared
US and European, ranked
HiPP Dutch Stage 1 Combiotik
Check Availability
Buy 3, get 4 with free shipping for new customers, plus a Right Formula Guarantee.
What I liked
- Complete organic formula that’s close to breastmilk
- No corn syrup solids, starch, maltodextrin or gluten
- Prebiotic and probiotic in the same tin
- Includes DHA and ARA
- Easy ordering from an established U.S. distributor
What could be better
- Not in US stores, so plan your orders
Why I chose to buy it
I’d never heard of HiPP until my massage therapist mentioned it; she had recommended it to other parents she worked with and they kept coming back to her with good news. I looked it up expecting marketing fluff. What sold me was the ingredient list: lactose, organic skim milk, vegetable oils without palm oil, a prebiotic, a probiotic, DHA. No corn syrup solids, no maltodextrin, no starch. It read like the shortest list of the eight, and the one closest to what I was trying to replace.
My experience using HiPP Dutch
I ordered a single can to try. My baby took the first bottle without a fuss, which had not happened with the store formulas we tried before it. Over the first couple of weeks the spit-up that had been wearing us all down settled for us, and he started staying full between feeds instead of rooting around an hour later. I’m not a doctor and every baby is different, but for us it was the first formula that didn’t feel like a compromise. Five months in, we’ve moved up to the Stage 2 and I haven’t looked back.
Two practical notes. You can’t grab it at Target: I order it from a US distributor that ships from a US warehouse in 2–5 business days, and I order a month at a time so we never run out on a Sunday night. And the scoop chart is in grams and millilitres, so I wrote the ounces equivalent on a card and taped it inside the cupboard door. They currently run a buy 3, get 4 starter pack for new customers, which is how I’d start if I were doing this again.
Summary
When it comes to something like my baby’s only food, for me, I’m willing to go above and beyond to get it right, which is why I researched high and low. I’m so happy I did because HiPP Dutch is the first formula my little guy has been genuinely settled on. Organic, close to breast milk, and he thrives on it.
What I liked
- Contains prebiotics
- DHA from plant sources (fully vegetarian)
- Non-GMO
- Organic whole milk
- No palm oil
- Easy ordering from established U.S. distributor
What could be better
- Doesn’t have a probiotic
My experience with Kendamil Organic
Kendamil is what I fed my first for most of that first year, and I’d still point a friend to it. It’s made in the UK from organic whole milk, so the fat comes from milk rather than palm oil, and the DHA comes from algae. My oldest did well on it, and it mixes easily without foaming. The reason it isn’t my winner is simple: there is no probiotic in the tin, and when my second had trouble, it wasn’t enough on its own.
Summary
A very close second, slightly cheaper per can, and from the same distributor. If your baby is doing fine on it, I wouldn’t switch.
What I liked
- Organic whole goat milk, Demeter-certified farms
- A gentle option if cow’s milk formula isn’t agreeing with your baby
- Includes DHA
What could be better
- Contains maltodextrin alongside the lactose
- No prebiotics or probiotics
- Pricier per can
My experience with Holle Goat
Holle Goat was my first instinct when the spit-up started, because every mom group I’m in says “try goat” the moment you mention reflux. It did seem a little gentler for us, and the milk comes from biodynamic farms, which I like. But it wasn’t the whole answer for my baby, the tin smells like, well, goat milk, and once I started reading labels the maltodextrin and the lack of any pre- or probiotic bugged me. HiPP also makes a goat version, which is on my list to try, but the Combiotik is what settled him.
Summary
If your pediatrician points you toward goat milk, this is a solid, clean option. For an everyday formula, HiPP or Kendamil give you more in the tin for less.
What I liked
- The shortest ingredient list of the eight
- Lactose only, no maltodextrin in Stage 1
- Bioland organic, no palm oil
- Usually the most affordable European option
What could be better
- No prebiotics or probiotics
- Stage 2 and 3 add maltodextrin, so check the tin when you move up
My experience with Lebenswert
Lebenswert is Holle’s simpler cousin: organic cow’s milk, lactose, oils, vitamins, done. It was the first European formula a friend mentioned to me, and I ran a can of it during our search. It’s also usually the cheapest of the European options. I moved on because I wanted the prebiotic and probiotic, but for a “clean and simple” formula it’s hard to beat.
Summary
Great value and a very clean label. If your budget is tight and your baby is doing well, Lebenswert is a solid choice.
What I liked
- Hydrolyzed (broken-down) milk protein for babies who need it
- Same prebiotic and probiotic as the Combiotik range
- Includes DHA
What could be better
- Not organic
- Contains starch; mixes thicker
- Only worth it if your pediatrician points you this way
My experience with HiPP HA
I bought one can of the HA when I was convinced my baby had a protein issue. He didn’t, and we went back to the regular Dutch Combiotik, but I keep it on this list because it’s the one I’d try, with my pediatrician’s okay, if he had. It has the same pre- and probiotic combination as my winner, the protein is hydrolyzed, and it isn’t organic.
Summary
A specialist formula, not an everyday one. Talk to your doctor first.
What I liked
- USDA organic and easy to find in US stores
- Includes DHA and ARA
- Affordable
What could be better
- Corn syrup solids replace most of the lactose
- No probiotic
- Didn’t help with the fussiness for us
My experience with Earth’s Best Sensitivity
This was the second store formula I tried with my younger baby, chosen because it says organic on the front and “sensitivity” on the label. The organic part is true. The sweetener, though, is corn syrup solids, which is the opposite of what I was looking for by then. He was about the same on it as on the Similac, which is to say still spitting up and still hungry an hour later.
Summary
The best of the three US formulas I tried, and a fine option if you need something from the store shelf today. Read the back of the tin, not the front.
What I liked
- Non-GMO
- Has a prebiotic (2’-FL HMO) and DHA
- In every store
What could be better
- Corn syrup is the first ingredient
- Not organic
- Made my baby fussy
My experience with Similac Pro-Sensitive
This is what the hospital sent us home with both times, and what most of my friends use, so it’s where I started with my second. It does what it says on the tin for a lot of babies. For mine, the spit-up didn’t let up and he never seemed satisfied, and when I finally read the ingredients I understood why I wanted to look further: corn syrup is the very first ingredient.
Summary
Nothing wrong with it if your baby is happy on it. If yours isn’t, this is the point where I’d start looking at the European options.
What I liked
- Non-GMO
- Affordable
What could be better
- Smells horrible
- Made my baby fussy
- Very foamy
My experience with Similac Pro-Total Comfort
The pediatrician’s office suggested this one when the Pro-Sensitive wasn’t working. The protein is partially broken down, which some babies need. Ours didn’t take to it: the smell is strong, it foams up like a milkshake when you shake it (and I’m particular about how a bottle mixes), and the spit-up didn’t change for us.
Summary
If your doctor recommends a partially hydrolyzed formula, there are versions of this from HiPP too (the HA above). I’d rather go that route.
Comparison chart
Considering all of my important factors for a formula (listed above), I created this comparison chart with the help of a friend (she’s a mom of twins who went through exactly the same search). Everything here can be found on the respective formula’s nutrition label or website.
| Organic | Lactose only | Prebiotic | Probiotic | DHA | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ideal formula | |||||
| winnerHiPP Dutch | |||||
| Kendamil Organic | |||||
| Holle Goat | |||||
| Lebenswert | |||||
| HiPP HA | |||||
| Earth’s Best Sensitivity | |||||
| Similac Pro-Sensitive | |||||
| Similac Pro-Total Comfort |
*comparison across the criteria that mattered to me. “Lactose only” means no corn syrup solids, glucose syrup or maltodextrin in the Stage 1 tin.
Why I chose HiPP Dutch as the best baby formula
To recap, formula is the only thing my babies have ever eaten, so for me it’s worth going above and beyond to get it right, which is why I researched high and low. I’m so happy I did because HiPP Dutch settled my second baby in a way nothing else did: organic, lactose-based, with the prebiotic and probiotic that most tins leave out, and from a US distributor that has never let me down on a delivery.
If you want to try it, start with the buy 3, get 4 starter pack. It’s the cheapest way in, and the Right Formula Guarantee means you’re not stuck with cans if your baby disagrees with me.
Look, mamas. We have enough to worry about. Some things don’t go as planned (breastfeeding wasn’t our path, and I made peace with that early) but that doesn’t mean you have to feel shame or guilt about it. Resources are out there for a reason. Considering all of my important factors for a formula (listed above), I created this comparison chart so you don’t have to start from scratch like I did.
There’s never a reason to be anxious about this or go in blind. I hope this blog helps you make the right decisions for your baby. Reach out if you need support and never forget you’re doing a damn good job, mama!
Real talk: I may earn an affiliate revenue when you purchase via my blog. This keeps it free of ads. Thanks for your support!
This page is my personal experience as a parent and is not medical advice. Breast milk is the best food for infants. Please talk to your pediatrician about your baby’s feeding, and always follow the preparation instructions on the tin.